Employment and Industrial Relations Update: Court of Appeal Decides that Salary Adjustments Need Not be Automatically Provided and Annual Salary Increments Can be Based on Performance
The Court of Appeal in the recent case of Kesatuan Kebangsaan Pekerja – Pekerja Hotel, Bar dan Restoran, Semenanjung Malaysia v CDL Hotels (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd (Grand Millennium Kuala Lumpur)1 considered the issues of Salary Adjustments and Salary Increments in the 1st Collective Agreement between the National Union and the Grand Millennium Kuala Lumpur (“Hotel”).
Amongst the National Union’s contentions during the appeal were that:
- as part of the 1st Collective, there must be an immediate adjustment in salary; and
- annual salary increments should be based on a fixed rate without consideration of the employee’s performance.
The Court of Appeal delivered its decision on 6 November 2026 and unanimously dismissed the National Union’s appeal. In its decision, the Court of Appeal held as follows:
- In determining salary adjustments, it was necessary to also factor in the increments provided by the employer prior to the coming into force of the new collective agreement. This is consistent with existing case law such as Baxter Healthcare S.A. (Malaysia Operations) (Pulau Pinang) v Kesatuan Pekerja – Pekerja Baxter Healthcare S.A. (Malaysia Operations)2 and Tri-Wall (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd v Paper and Paper Products Manufacturing Employees’ Union & Mahkamah Perusahaan Malaysia3. In this particular case, the Hotel had provided salary increments prior to the 1st Collective Agreement and, as such, there should not be any immediate salary adjustments as demanded by the National Union.
- The Court of Appeal further rejected the National Union’s contention that since all the employees had been provided with the minimum wage, there should be a “domino effect” and employees above the minimum wage should also receive small increments.
- The National Union’s proposal that there is a fixed yearly increment for employees without taking into account the employee’s performance was not in tandem with the legal position. The fact that an employee has completed an additional year of service does not automatically mean that the employee is more skillful. An example would be that an employee with 10 years experience need not necessarily be more skillful than an employee with five years experience. Furthermore, current performance of an employee does not guarantee future performance.
The Court of Appeal’s decision provided clarity that immediate salary adjustments need not be provided in the 1st Collective Agreement where salary increments were provided in the previous years. In addition, annual salary increments should not be provided “automatically” simply because the employee had completed another year of service and the Hotel was entitled to insist that annual increments to determined based on performance, rather than the length of service.
The Hotel was represented before the Court of Appeal by Vijayan Venugopal together with Wong Kian Jun, who are both Partners in our Employment and Industrial Relations Practice.
Footnotes:
- Civil Appeal W-01(A)-325-07/2025.
- [1995] 2 ILR 534.
- Judicial Review No: R2-25-115-2011].
COPYRIGHT © 2026 SHEARN DELAMORE & CO. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
THIS UPDATE IS ISSUED FOR THE INFORMATION OF THE CLIENTS OF THE FIRM AND COVERS LEGAL ISSUES IN A GENERAL WAY.
THE CONTENTS ARE NOT INTENDED TO CONSTITUTE ANY ADVICE ON ANY SPECIFIC MATTER AND SHOULD NOT BE RELIED UPON AS A SUBSTITUTE FOR DETAILED LEGAL ADVICE ON SPECIFIC MATTERS OR TRANSACTIONS.